Inputs and costs

Certified seed or saved seed: what each costs over a season

The bag has a price on the label; the tin from last season's store does not, but it still charges you — in thinner stands, degenerating potato lines, and grain bought back from a trader at planting.

Of all the numbers on a farm, the price of certified seed in Kenya is the easiest to find. It is printed on the bag and quoted over the counter. Saved seed is the hardest, because nobody prints it. You pay for it in a thinner stand, in grain sold cheaply at harvest and bought back dearly at planting, in a potato line that gets a little sicker each year the same tubers go back in. This piece puts the two prices side by side, crop by crop, and says where the sealed bag earns its money and where the tin from the store is the sensible choice.

From our own stations

Measured by NuaSense weather stations and soil probes on Kenyan farms, over the period stated with each figure. Past readings, not a forecast.

22 %
Hours scoring 60+ for spraying
114 mm
November rainfall, 43-year mean
19.4 °C
Mean air temperature
A weather station low in a flowering potato field under blue sky
A weather station low in a flowering potato field under blue sky Photo: NuaSense

A counter, a budget, and the line that gets cut first

Planting is close. The rains have started somewhere, and a manager stands in an agrovet with cash for fertiliser, a knapsack refill and seed. Seed is the line easiest to cut, because there is grain at home. That grain grew on the same soil, came off a crop that left a surplus, and costs nothing today. Next to it, a certified bag costs real money today and promises something it cannot show you: a cleaner, truer stand in six weeks.

Put honestly, this is a timing problem as much as a quality one. Certified seed pulls the cost to the start of the season, when cash is scarcest and the whole input bill lands at once. Saved seed pushes it to the middle and the end, where it hides in yield, in disease and in the grain trade. Compare only what leaves your pocket on planting day and you will pick saved seed every year, because on planting day saved seed is free. Compare what the season returns and you will pick differently for different crops. That is the point: there is no single answer.

Since 2020 there has been a third thing on the shelf: the Standard Certified Seed class. CIMMYT's account of the standard certified seed programme describes it as a bridge between fully certified seed and informal farmer-saved seed, built for open-pollinated and vegetatively propagated crops including indigenous vegetables. It was meant to be a cheaper labelled option. So far it has struggled to be cheap. That struggle shows where the money in a seed bag actually goes, which is the next question.

Four things you can put in the ground, side by side

Set it out the way a grower would: cash today, cost later, what it buys, and what it legally is. No prices appear here. None of the sources give a bag price, and an invented range would be worse than none.

  • Fully certified seed | Cash today: the full bag price, paid at planting when cash is tightest | Cost later: little, if the seller was genuine and the packet sealed | What it buys: inspected fields, laboratory testing, a traceable label, a known variety | Legal status: certified under the Seeds and Plant Varieties Act, regulated by KEPHIS
  • Standard certified seed (SCS) | Cash today: meant to sit below the fully certified price, but production costs have limited that advantage | Cost later: similar to certified for disease, since disease tolerance limits were largely kept | What it buys: fewer field inspections, shorter isolation distances, adjusted off-type allowances, still a label | Legal status: a recognised certified class since 2020, for open-pollinated and vegetatively propagated crops
  • Farmer-saved or market seed | Cash today: nothing, or the grain price if bought from a trader or neighbour | Cost later: variety drift, seed-borne disease build-up, replacement at trader prices after a failed season | What it buys: local adaptation, availability where no company sells seed, control over timing | Legal status: informal; not certified, not labelled, not traceable
  • Quality declared seed (QDS) | Cash today: typically lower than certified, where it exists | Cost later: no quality guarantee, and an agrovet cannot stock it | What it buys: a trained local multiplier starting from certified stock | Legal status: not recognised by Kenyan law because it is not certified, so it is deemed illegal

Two rows deserve more attention than they get. SCS exists because full certification could not profitably serve sorghum, cowpea, green gram and indigenous vegetables. The informal row exists because, for those same crops, it is nearly the only supply there is. QDS is the trap. To a buyer it looks like SCS, and the Springer study of how Kenyan potato farmers evaluate seed is explicit that quality declared seed is not recognised by law in Kenya, because it is not certified. An agrovet who stocks it is exposed, whatever the quality in the sack.

Inside the bag price: inspectors, isolation and diesel

A certified bag costs what it does because somebody paid for inspectors to walk a field more than once, for isolation distance that took land out of other use, for sampling and laboratory testing, for a label and for a lorry. The seed itself is a small part of that. The rest is the cost of being able to trust it. The CIMMYT report is frank about why that cost runs high in Kenya: seed companies often have to operate across multiple locations to meet certification standards, and many standard seed growers register plots of less than one acre in scattered locations. That makes efficient inspection difficult and pushes the cost per kilogram upwards.

Then there is distance. Localising seed production, the same report notes, can save farmers significant costs, because transporting seed from distant regions is expensive. For bulky seed that is the largest hidden cost in the bag. The potato study makes the point from the other side: under a decentralised multiplier model, local availability cuts transport cost, given the bulkiness, perishability and sheer quantity of seed potato a field needs. A bag sold in a county with no seed production in it is carrying diesel in its price.

That is why the same variety sells at different prices in different towns. the post on why the same bag costs more at one agrovet than the next works through the same pattern for inputs generally. It also explains the regulator's posture. KEPHIS was established in October 1996 under the Seeds and Plant Varieties Act (CAP 326), with regional offices in Nairobi, Mombasa, Nakuru and Kitale. KEPHIS certifies seed. It does not set or publish retail prices. What you are quoted comes from the seed company and the stockist. It is built on inspection, isolation and transport. Nothing on the label tells you the margin. Only comparing stockists does.

Saved seed: free on planting day, paid for later

The last true thing anyone says about saved seed is zero cash on planting day. From there the costs begin, and farmers in dry areas know the first one best. An FAO review of seed relief in Kenya's drylands records that a proportion of farmers frequently run short of seed after extended droughts. Seed stocks get eaten as food when the crop fails. Seed that was free is now gone, and it must be bought back.

Bought back from whom, and at what price, is the second cost. That same review describes local traders who buy grain at harvest, store it, and sell it back later to the same farmers as food or as seed at planting time. In effect it is a seasonal loan with the interest hidden in the gap between the harvest price and the planting price. A grower who sold grain into the glut and buys it back as seed in the shortage has paid for seed, paid a trader's storage and margin, and still planted uncertified grain of unknown variety and health. That is the worst of both options, and it is the common result of calling saved seed free.

The third cost is biological, and it compounds. In grain crops you get variety drift and the slow build-up of seed-borne problems. In tubers there is something far worse, and the next section covers that. The fourth cost is labour and attention. Selecting, drying, storing and protecting seed through a long dry season is work. Store it carelessly and it is grain by planting time. None of these sits on a budget line. All of them turn up in the yield. A fair comparison puts a value on each one, even a rough one, because the alternative is pretending the tin from the store cost nothing.

Potatoes: the crop where recycling tubers costs most

If one crop makes the money case for buying seed, it is potato, and the sources are blunt about it. The Springer study reports that the informal system dominates the seed potato supply smallholders use. Farmers re-use saved tubers and buy from local markets and neighbours. Quality is poor because of degeneration: the accumulation of seed-borne pests and diseases in the tuber line over time. A potato grown from last year's potato carries last year's problems and adds this year's. Each generation starts a little sicker than the one before.

Supply makes the problem worse. Over 30 registered seed merchants produce certified seed potato in Kenya and still supply less than 5 percent of what farmers plant. No certified production takes place in the north rift region at all, even though every region there except Turkana grows potatoes at some scale. A grower there chooses between saved tubers and a long, expensive haul of bulky seed from elsewhere. That haul puts transport back into the price.

What turns this into a money question, not a growing question, is what the study found: seed potato is among the biggest financial outlays Kenyan smallholders face. Their willingness to pay a premium is wholly contingent on a material benefit: food security, yield, marketability, economic return. Some seed producers report being unable to sell their seed despite the assumed benefits. Farmers named 38 attributes they look for in seed potato. Users and non-users of certified seed use the same ones, so non-users already know what good seed is. They are not ignorant. They are unconvinced the premium pays. Varieties, soils and planting seasons are the business of NuaSense's guide to growing potatoes in Kenya, which covers where and when to plant, soil and pH, and fertiliser and disease control. On the money side the position is simpler: once a tuber line is visibly degenerating, saved seed is the expensive option, whatever the bag price.

Maize is different, and the seed companies were built around it

Maize is the exception to almost everything said about seed in Kenya. Kenya's National Seed Policy records that in 2007 the national requirement for certified seed ran between 28,000 and 35,000 metric tonnes. Seed maize made up about 80 percent of that total. From the other side, the FAO dryland review puts certified seed at under 5 percent of what is sown in the arid and semi-arid lands, except for maize. Kenya's 38 registered seed companies were built around that crop. They include Kenya Seed Company, East African Seed Company, Western Grain and Seed Company and Faida Seeds, which lead the group.

If you plant hybrids, the save-or-buy question hardly comes up. Seed from a hybrid crop does not come true, so the choice is between a hybrid bag, an open-pollinated bag or local grain — never between buying and saving the same thing. That changes the whole comparison. It is no longer whether the bag pays against the store, but which bag, from which company, at which stockist. Maize is the one crop where a Kenyan buyer has that choice of company and stockist in most towns. So shopping between agrovets pays on seed the way it does on fertiliser, and the diesel the earlier section put inside the price shows up in the spread between quotes. Ask two stockists. Then ask a third.

An open-pollinated maize that has performed well brings the saved-seed arguments back, and drought replacement weighs heaviest in the drier counties, where the FAO review names maize as the one crop that does move through the certified channel. Even there the money question is the same six lines set out later: cash today, replacement risk, and what a trader will charge at planting for grain you could have kept. What maize adds is a market for the label itself. So much seed maize moves through certification that the counter checks are worth running — and that is also what makes a fake worth making. The bag carrying the most trust is the one that most needs checking.

A footpath through a flowering potato field under grey cloud
A footpath through a flowering potato field under grey cloud Photo: NuaSense

Dryland legumes and cereals: often no bag to compare against

Switch to sorghum, millet, cowpea, green gram or pigeonpea and one side of the decision is often empty. The FAO review states that private companies find seed of arid and semi-arid crops expensive to produce and market, with demand unreliable. So very little certified seed of these open-pollinated crops is produced, and none for vegetatively propagated crops. Informal seed accounts for over 90 percent of what is sown in the drylands. For many of these crops there is no sealed bag to price saved seed against.

This is a national matter, not a corner case. Arid and semi-arid lands cover approximately 80 percent of Kenya and carry over 20 percent of its people and 50 percent of its livestock, yet produce about 5 percent of agricultural output. All 13 districts of eastern Kenya sit in agro-ecological zones 3 to 7. Eastern Province holds about 3.8 million people, and farms there run between 2 and 7 hectares per household, with 30 to 50 percent of family land cropped. A great deal of the planting is done from stores, markets and neighbours.

Here the money logic turns on the year after a failure. In a normal year saved seed is the right call: adapted, available, free. After a drought it becomes the dear call, when stocks have been eaten and the trader's planting-time price applies. Relief seed is no rescue either. It can be exotic and unsuited to local conditions, and even where adapted varieties are handed out they are restricted to the few that companies hold, so local lines are lost and dependence continues; relief operations were often uncoordinated and turned beneficiaries into receivers rather than seed producers. One cheap lever remains. Keep a seed store apart from the food store, and do not sell into the harvest glut what will have to be bought back at planting.

SCS, the cheaper label that has not yet got cheap

Standard Certified Seed was built for exactly that gap. It relaxes certification by cutting the number of field inspections, lowering isolation distances and adjusting allowable off-types, while leaving disease tolerance limits largely intact. In the pilot, KEPHIS inspected, sampled and laboratory-tested 106 metric tons of sorghum, green gram and cowpea, and a portion of that was certified and labelled.

At scale, the cheaper label has not reached the shops, and the CIMMYT report says why. High production costs limit the price advantage of standard seed. Growers register sub-acre plots in scattered places, inspection is inefficient, and the online certification systems have had technical difficulties. Seed companies hesitate to invest because profitability is unclear and they want sharper differentiation in price and quality from full certification. Farmer awareness of SCS for dryland crops is low, so demand has not pulled the product through, and climate-related irrigation needs on seed plots add to the bill.

For a buyer that is a caution and a hope. The caution: an SCS label is a genuine certified class, a different thing from quality declared seed, which an agrovet cannot legally stock, so ask which it is. The hope: KEPHIS says it is ready to train more private community inspectors and district inspectors to manage the standard class, and that is the one move that attacks inspection cost directly. If it lands in your county, an SCS price for a dryland legume could come close enough to saved seed that the drought-replacement risk tips it. Until then, buy SCS when it is actually on the shelf and ask for it when it is not; stockists order what customers ask about.

A six-line sum you can do on a phone

Nowhere in this piece will you find a bag price for your crop, or a yield gap between certified and saved seed. We won't invent either one. Run the figures yourself, and put down the low end of what you expect, not the hopeful end. You will see no numbers in what follows, because the numbers are yours.

  1. Write the certified cost per acre: bag price at the stockist you would actually use, times bags per acre, plus transport home. This is the only side with a receipt.
  2. Write the saved seed cash cost per acre: zero if it is in your store, or the grain price you would pay a trader or neighbour at planting time if it is not. Be honest about which applies this season.
  3. Write the replacement risk: the share of recent seasons in which you had to buy seed back after a failure, times the trader's planting-time price. In the drylands this line is often larger than the bag price.
  4. Write the yield you expect from each, at the low end, times the farm-gate price you expect at harvest. If you cannot estimate a difference, write the same yield for both and let the risk line decide.
  5. For potato, add a degeneration line: how many seasons the current tuber line has been recycled, and what the stand looked like last season. If it is already failing, the saved-seed yield line is a guess that gets worse each year.
  6. Subtract. The option with the higher expected return after seed cost and risk is the buy. If the two sit within the error of your own guesses, choose saved seed and spend the difference on something with a clearer return.

Two of those lines hinge on what grain fetches at two points in the year: harvest and planting. County market prices are published in the open at agriculture-data.com, and the NuaSense dashboard shows them free beside a farm's own station readings. That is the fastest way to see how wide the gap between those two prices runs in your county, before you sell grain now and buy seed later.

Save, buy, or walk out: the position

Save your own seed when the crop is open-pollinated or self-pollinated. Save it when the line is one you chose and it has done well for you, when your seed store is kept apart from the food store and will come through a long dry season, and when no certified or SCS option is within reach at a price you can defend. For most dryland legumes and cereals outside maize, that is the normal year, and it is what over 90 percent of growers in those areas already do. Buy when the crop is hybrid. Buy when it is potato and the line is degenerating, when last season's failure emptied the store and the trader's price is your alternative, and when a certified or SCS bag for your crop sits on the shelf of a stockist you trust. And buy nothing at all, planting later or less, rather than take grain of unknown origin repackaged as seed.

When you do buy, the premium only pays if the bag is what it claims to be. The regulator's advice on that is short. In its guidance on seed certification services, KEPHIS tells buyers to use recognised dealers or stockists who display their licence and company name, to steer clear of seed weighed out of opened packets, to insist on an official receipt, and to keep the empty packets and labels so the seed can be traced if something goes wrong. A sealed packet is the only evidence that the certification you paid for actually reached the seed in your hand. The post on spotting fake fertiliser and seed before you pay walks through the counter checks in more detail.

For the agrovet the picture is the mirror image. Stock certified and SCS seed for the crops your customers plant, label the difference between the two, refuse quality declared seed however good the sack looks, and never split a sealed packet. Your customers are already weighing the bag against the store at home. Those who buy will pay the premium only if they trust the seller more than the tin at home, and that trust is the one thing in the shop that costs nothing to produce.

Sources

  1. Bridging the seed gap in Kenya with standard certified seed, CIMMYT. SCS launch in 2020, relaxed inspection and isolation rules, 106 t pilot, cost drivers, company hesitancy, KEPHIS inspector training
  2. Towards effective and sustainable seed relief activities, FAO. ASAL land, population and output shares, certified seed under 5 percent except maize, informal over 90 percent, 38 seed companies, trader buy-back, relief seed problems
  3. How Kenyan Potato Farmers Evaluate the Seed, Springer Nature. Seed potato degeneration, over 30 merchants supplying under 5 percent, no north rift production, 38 attributes, QDS not legal, willingness to pay
  4. National Seed Policy, Ministry of Agriculture, Kenya. 2007 national certified seed requirement of 28,000 to 35,000 t, seed maize about 80 percent
  5. Seed Certification Services, KEPHIS. KEPHIS founding date, CAP 326, regional offices, buyer advice on dealers, sealed packets, receipts and labels

Questions we get asked

Is saved seed always cheaper than certified seed in Kenya?

No. It costs nothing on planting day, but after a failed season the same grain is bought back from traders at planting-time prices, and recycled seed potato gets sicker each generation. Price the risk, not just the bag.

Does KEPHIS set the price of certified seed?

No. KEPHIS inspects, tests and certifies seed under the Seeds and Plant Varieties Act. Prices are set by seed companies and stockists, so compare agrovets.

Is standard certified seed the same as quality declared seed?

No. Standard certified seed is a recognised certified class launched in 2020 with fewer inspections. Quality declared seed is not certified and is not recognised by Kenyan law, so an agrovet should not stock it.

Which crop is the worst to save seed from?

Potato. Degeneration from seed-borne pests and diseases builds up in recycled tubers, and certified seed potato supplies less than 5 percent of what farmers plant, so the gap between good and poor seed is wide.

What should I check before paying for a certified bag?

A recognised dealer displaying licence and company name, a sealed packet rather than seed weighed from an opened one, an official receipt, and keep the empty packet and label.

See harvest and planting prices in your county before you sell grain

The NuaSense dashboard puts public county market prices next to a farm's own station and soil readings. A weather station costs KES 30,000 and a soil sensor KES 7,000, excluding taxes, with a money-back guarantee in the first three months.

Ask about a station